Case Briefs
Database For Canadian Criminal Law

 R. v. Ikuta

List of Similar Cases | Add Data to This Case | Edit

  Home |Add a new case | List of Issues 
Search for a Case by Name, Cite, Issue, Facts and Reasons

Find A Case That Starts With

Canadian lawyers and Judges are invited to add Additional Issues, Facts, Reasons, Anecdotes, History, Comments, Distinguished, Overruled, Approved, Considered, Corrections, or anything else helpful to readers by clicking the Add Data to This Case hyperlink above. 

ID: 305

Title: R. v. Ikuta

Cite: [2000] O.J. No. 2764

Court: ON CJ

Date: 16/05/2000

Justices: Sheppard J.

Result: Accused acquitted

WhoWon: D

Issue: Interpreter During RTC


Charges: Over 80


 

Facts

Drunk Driving over 80 case, accused's first language is Japanese, used English in business but had difficulty in some words; police stopped him read his rights did breath demand all in English, spoke to duty council, was never offered an intetpreter. Edit


Reasons

"Persons without working knowledge in English or French are particularly likely to feel vulnerable to an authority system they see as incomprehensible". Therefore, this court would find, based on the video, that although there is a working knowledge; there was not knowledge sufficient in this accused given his answers to the definitions of the relevant words and given the Court's observations of the video, his knowledge was not sufficient to fully understand the provisions surrounding impaired driving and driving over 80. Edit


 Biss Private Use Only


 
Click this link to Add Your Comments about: R. v. Ikuta
Click here to Add a Hyperlink re  R. v. Ikuta

Biss Private Use Only